Skip to main content Land State Government of Victoria - link to Victorian Government home

land.vic.gov.au

Home > Professions > Valuation > Valuations for Government Property Transactions Printer Friendly Version

Guidelines for Departments and Agencies Procuring Services from the Valuation Services and Allied Disciplines Panels

Purpose

The purpose of this document is to describe the procedure to be followed by Government Departments and Agencies in contracting out valuations to Valuation firms of the Valuation Services (VSP) and Allied Disciplines Panels (ADP), established by Valuer-General Victoria.

The latest panels commenced operation from 1/9/06 and are valid for 3 years.

Background

Departments and Agencies when purchasing valuations may choose between:

  • a certified Valuer-General Valuation*; or
  • a non-certified valuation from the VSP, monitored by Valuer-General Victoria (VGV).

*A certified Valuer-General valuation may consist of:
  • a valuation made by the Valuer-General; or
  • a valuation made by a member of the Valuer-General’s Panel which has been obtained from the VGV and the Valuer-General confirms in writing that it has been properly made and based.

Scope

These guidelines apply to all dealings with a value of less than $250,000, except those affected by the Government’s Policy and Instructions on the purchase, compulsory acquisition, and sale of land administered by the Government Land Monitor.

References

This document refers to the following documents:
  1. Property Valuations for the State Government of Victoria - A Statement of Guidelines for Valuation Practices, November 2001
  2. Government of Victoria Policy and Instructions for the Purchase, Compulsory Acquisition and Sale of Land Administered by the Government Land Monitor
  3. Request for Valuation Forms

Definitions

(VSP) – Valuation Services Panel
(ADP) - Allied Disciplines Panel
(VGV) – Valuer-General Victoria
(GLM) – Government Land Monitor
(VGPB) – Victorian Government Purchasing Board

Actions

When Departments have identified suitable properties available for disposal, purchase or compulsory acquisition they should determine the appropriate valuation requirements according to the Statement of Guidelines for the Valuer-General and Government Land Monitor Policy.

It is recommended that quotations for valuation services be obtained from the list of VSP Valuers. However, it should be noted that purchase of a valuation from the VSP does not guarantee probity or independence of the valuation, or capability to deliver soundly based and timely valuation advice for every request. The current financial delegations of your Department will apply for the purchase of these services. These valuations will not be certified Valuer-General’s valuations.

When appropriate, properties should be batched in groups by geographical locality to enable optimum cost effectiveness. Potential duplication of effort and cost overruns will be minimised through contingency planning. Tenders should be obtained for valuation services from the VSP, based on the current financial guidelines from the Victorian Government Purchasing Board (VGPB).

When calling for quotes or tenders from valuation firms the Property Officer should ensure that:
  • The instructions are clear and the valuer understands the scope of the valuation advice that is required;
  • The valuer should declare any ‘conflict of interest’ in providing these services and a statement to this effect should be included with the quotations. Valuers are to declare any commercial interest – property, business or professional, prior to accepting instructions from your department when undertaking a particular valuation;
  • The time line for the assignment is feasible and includes a projected completion date; and
  • The fee and/or basis for the fee for the assignment are in accordance with your department policies and with VGPB guidelines.

Appointment of Valuer

On receipt of the quotations the successful tenderer should be appointed. The quotations should be filed and the reasons for the successful tender should be documented.

Acceptance of the quotation should be confirmed with the valuer in his letter of instruction. The agreed timeline, the agreed fee and instructions to carry out the valuation and any special conditions, qualifications or requirements should also be confirmed in writing.

It is suggested that Valuer-General Victoria (VGV) Request for Valuation Form could be usefully adapted by Departments when instructing contract valuers, to assist with the valuation of the subject property, noting that it will not be a valuation for VGV but a valuation direct to your department.

The valuer is required to warrant the confidentiality of all information obtained whilst undertaking the valuation assessment.

The Property Officer should ensure that:
  • The identified information requirements are sufficient for property identification and inspection. Appropriate survey plans, title information and any other relevant plans should be included to assist the valuer to identify the subject property; and
  • The appropriate contact person is specified for property inspection purposes.
The Property Officer must not disclose any details, which might be regarded as influencing the valuer’s independence during the valuation process.

Valuation Specifications

The contract valuer conducts a property inspection, inspects comparable sale properties, analyses data and prepares a report. The valuation specifications set out details required in the content of the valuation report. At least three (3) sales should be included with the report, with details of comparability with the subject property and valuation rationale. That is, some discussion as to how the valuation was arrived at, so the property officer has a clear understanding of the valuer’s basis of valuation.

The property officer should read the valuation report to ensure that it complies with his/her original instructions.

When agencies use members of the VSP direct, VGV cannot certify the valuations as meeting VGV standards for Quality and Accuracy.

Conferences / Disputes

Where a formal conference of valuers is requested by your department to resolve a valuation dispute, it will be chaired by the VGV Manager, Government Valuations, or nominated persons.

Your department should request VGV to arrange and conduct a conference. Details of the matter in dispute should be provided and copies of both valuations should be provided to VGV prior to the conference, preferably with the conference instructions.

The conference will be held in the most convenient location to minimise travelling and expenses for all parties.

Following the conference, the Chairman will provide a written report to your department detailing the matters discussed and the result of any outcomes reached.

A fee, on the basis of cost recovery, will be charged to your department by VGV for attendance at such a conference.

Valuer-General Victoria – Request for Valuation Forms

These forms may be used to request Valuer-General Certified Valuations.

It is also suggested that the forms could be usefully modified for the request of non-certified valuations from the VSP.


"Request for Valuation" and "Request for Rental Valuation" Forms




This document was last reviewed on 23/05/2008.
© 2007 by the State of Victoria